For Sale - High Purity Helium-3, Nitrogen-15 and Oxygen-18

— Draft listing. Nearly complete. Tender duration and minimum bid values still to be determined —

20160410

I have for sale: five small laboratory type cylinders of rare, high purity stable isotope gases. Includes two liters of Helium-3. These are all from a retired CSIRO scientist's deceased estate, with provenance.

Detailed photos further down. The cylinders pictured above are for sale, and are:

  1. One cylinder of Helium-3.    99.95+%   Contains < 0.05% 4He.   2L
    Cambridge Isotope Laboratories.   Lot I-2306   5-92. Stainless cylinder.
    Has intact 'full' tag. Original end cap on outlet, no sign it was ever removed. The "2L" means contents are two liters gas volume at STP (standard temperature and 1 atmosphere pressure.)
    Note: The yellow tag has started to break slightly along one side of the 'empty' tear-off line, due to being flexed while curled. I'll put a little sticky tape on that edge to stop the tear progressing further.
  2. One cylinder of Nitrogen-15.   99/    2L
    Cambridge Isotope Laboratories.   Lot EB-314   5-92. Stainless cylinder.
    Has intact 'full' tag. Original end cap on outlet, no sign it was ever removed.
  3. One cylinder of Oxygen-18.   97.87%    2.034L
    Enritech Ltd (Israel) Can't see any date code or serial #. Yellow cylinder.
    Has intact 'full' tag. Original plug on outlet, no sign it was ever removed.
  4. Two cylinders of Oxygen-18. Mfr: CEA=ORIS Bureau des isotopes stables.
    White larger cylinders with mesh impact guards (which slide off and have been removed for the photo.)
All but one of the cylinders are as-new, with original seals intact, certainly never opened since manufacture and gas batch filling in the early 1990s. The fifth one has a supply nipple fitted, and its content remnant is unknown. But the fact it was kept by the person responsible for originally managing and storing all these, strongly suggests it was considered worthy of retention, therefore does contain appreciable original content.
All the valves were tightly closed as received. I checked by applying firm hand-torque to tighten them, and none moved. None of the valves have been opened at all since I received them. I use welding gas cylinders routinely, and am aware of the torque range to which gas valves should be tightened.

Also worth mentioning but probably of no commercial value are two other items that came with the above.
These are not included in the sale, and are mentioned only for the context they provide to the cylinders above.

Detail Photos

Cylinder 1, Helium-3 (click on thumbnails for 1000px image.)

Cylinder 2, Nitrogen-15

Cylinder 3, Oxygen-18

Cylinder 4a, Oxygen-18

Cylinder 4b, Oxygen-18

He-Ar Cylinder NOT INCLUDED IN SALE

Glass Ball of Oxygen-18 (maybe) NOT INCLUDED IN SALE

Provenance

Click here for a detailed account of the circumstances by which I was given these cylinders and other items.
(That is one section of a lengthy page, wait for it to load.)
See also a forum discussion: www.eevblog.com/forum/chat/unexpected-treasure-find/.

My friend's father was Leszek S Wielunski. He was a materials scientist, who worked for the CSIRO for many years up to the late 1990s. He died in 2015, with his son inheriting his posessions.

At left is a scan of his father's CSIRO business card.

On the 13th and 14th of March 2016 while I was helping my friend clear his family home in preparation for handover of the house, which had been sold, he gave many of those posessions to me. He plans to spend considerable time travelling, and did not want to be tethered to all these material things. He specifically included the crate of gas cylinders in the gifts to me, knowing they were valuable. (He was also amusing himself, wondering how long it would take me to realize their value. It took me two days.)

My friend's name is Andre Wielunski. Once I discovered what the cylinders contained, I checked with my friend that he had known that, known their potential value, and definitely intended me to have them.

Yes, he did, hence this signed statement he wrote out for me a few days later.

Another friend with more legal knowledge than either of us mentions the statement should have included mention of a consideration in order to be more solid. That was unfortunately accidentally omitted, but was assumed to be the hard work I'd put in, helping with clearing the house.

Also, mostly it was a gift from one friend to another, given that he knows my situation, interests and needs. That'd I'd absolutely understand and appreciate this gift, and could be trusted to not do something stupid like unseal and open the valve.

Sale by Public Tender

The cylinders listed are definitely all for sale, preferably but not necessarily as a set. This sale will be run as public tender, meaning interested buyers should submit bids by email. Bids are per cylinder, meaning you specify which ones you want, with a price for each one.

Bids for the 3He must be accompanied by supporting evidence of who you are, where you are (Country), and what you'll be using it for. I reserve the right to disregard bids for any reason.

At a closing date yet to be determined, I will notify successful bidder(s), if any. I will also post any successful purchase values, but not the buyer details. Any cylinders that received no bids meeting the minimum will remain on sale unless specifically withdrawn from sale.

The bidding deadline, and the minimum bid value considered for each of the cylinders are yet to be determined, while I research current typical market value. These details will be stated here when this page is finalized, in the near future. Be aware the minimum bid value will be determined with reference to current market price in US dollars.

In the meantime, if you are interested in purchasing any of these and you have references showing typical current market pricing for such items, you are welcome to contact me and discuss. Or you can just submit a bid.

The primary cause of difficulty in setting a minimum bid price is that the US government NIDC (National Isotope Development Center) runs yearly auctions of Helium-3 from their reserves, and the auction results are private. In that the resulting sale prices are not announced. They only state the minimum acceptable bid per liter. Here are some references:

US Gov Helium-3 Auctions
www.isotopes.gov/he-3auction2012 Fall 2012 Minimum bid price: US$2,500 per liter.
www.isotopes.gov/he-3auction2013 Summer 2013 Minimum bid price: US$2,675 per liter.
www.isotopes.gov/he-3auction Summer 2014 Minimum bid price: US$2,755 per liter.

From www.isotopes.gov/he-3auction/He-3_bid_invitation.pdf (2014 DOE bids solicitation):

"7. The minimum bid price which will be considered is $2,755 per liter. This does not include the cost of the cylinder, packaging and shipping."

"8. The minimum lot size which shall be considered is 25 liters of purified He-3 gas at STP (see attached product specifications in Attachment B). Bids shall not be accepted for lots smaller than 25 liters."

"13. He-3 gas shall be packaged by DOE in Size 6 or Size 30 compressed - gas cylinders, whichever is deemed appropriate by the DOE. The cylinders shall become the property of the Bidder. A Size 6 cylinder can package from 25 STP liters to 180 STP liters. The Size 30 cylinder can package from 200 STP liters up to 800 STP liters. Both cylinder sizes shall be fitted with a CGA 580 cylinder valve. The cost of the size 6 cylinder is $325.00 and the cost of the size 30 cylinder is $375.00. Different packaging instructions specified by the Bidder may require DOE Technical Services. The cost of the cylinders and any required DOE Technical Services shall be added by the DOE to the Form CA-10-90, rev 3."

I have not found information on any NIDC 3He auction for 2015 or 2016, so do not yet know their minimum bid then and this year. There's also the factors that their prices are for bulk supply (more than 25 liters), apparently they only sold to one or two major dealers like Linde, and hence prices to small end users of 3He would have considerable markup.

For potential buyers of these cylinders, there are obvious pros and cons besides the actual dollar pricing.

The Cons:

  1. No guarantee. As an individual with no way to actually test the contents (pressure and purity) of these cylinders, I am unable to guarantee their content is still as labelled. Interested parties will just have to evaluate the probability of the cylinders being as labelled, given the history and condition of the cylinders. If you want more photos or have questions, just ask.
  2. No return, no refund. The items cannot be returned, and no refunds will be given under any circumstances. I have accurately stated everything I know about these cylinders; you are bidding on them as they are. They are second hand goods, with no guarantee of contents or function.
  3. Payment up front in full. I'm not going to ship the cylinders off, and just hope a buyer is honest and won't claim the cylinder(s) were empty/contaminated, when they were fine. If a buyer wants these shipped somewhere, then they will have to pay up front and have funds cleared before I ship them. Payment accepted by cash if picking up in person, or by bank tranfer beforehand otherwise.
  4. Verification possibilities? I'm happy to see if some more mutually verified arrangement can be made. Perhaps testing of cylinder contents somewhere with both parties present? Or by a qualified third party? Shipping one of the lesser value cylinders first as touchstone? I'm open to suggestions.
  5. Shipping: Internation or domestic air shipping could be difficult or impossible, for multiple reasons. Although we know the cylinders are at relatively low pressure and perfectly safe, flight restrictions on pressure cylinders are a problem. To the uninformed they certainly look like high pressure cylinders, and would probably be rejected from air cargo on safety grounds if x-rayed. Maybe I'm wrong about this?
    Also as an individual sender I have no way to ensure some customs agent doesn't get it into their head to try opening a cylinder and doing a sniff test or whatever.
    Domestic surface shipping should be fine.
    As a buyer, if you can't pick up in person you'll have to instruct me in your choice of shipping, insurance and customs declaration.
    Finding some shipping means that works for these will be the buyer's responsibility.
    The shipping workability, details and costs must be finalized before payment is made.
The Pros:
  1. Small quantity. No need to buy in bulk, or pay the reseller markup. My minimum bid price will be chosen to be attractive relative to standard small quantity commercial sales. If you only want a couple of liters of He, here they are.
  2. Quick. No waiting a year for the next US NIDC auction, or even international shipping if the buyer is in Australia. In fact if you are in a hurry, make an offer now, and you could have it/them as soon as you can pick up and pay cash.
  3. No red tape. Just explain who you are and what you want them for, to satisfy my curiosity and self-protection in law. Easy. These would be sold on ebay, if I wanted to accept ebay's percentage cut. (Which I don't.)
  4. Good Karma. These are rare items, of considerable scientific interest to those able to use them. The circumstances of them becoming available like these must be even rarer. (Read the full background story.) I want to see them reach an appreciative buyer, and be useful. I'll do whatever I can to see that happen. But I do need the money, and it's for a highly worthy cause. Which is one of those quests where speaking of it publicly beforehand risks sinking chances of success. So I'll only explain f2f, and only if I decide the asker would appreciate the story. But by buying these, you will be contributing to a good deed — or at least a serious attempt at it.

No Sale, and other scenarios

It may turn out that due to the slight uncertainty of content with these cylinders and the awkward logistics of verification, there will be insufficient interest for them to sell. In that case I will be happy to keep them, since I do have my own vacuum system development project. For that I don't particularly require these rare gases, but do need multiple small lab-sized gas sample cylinders like these. More than I have here. The cylinders themselves are not cheap to buy, so they'll be appreciated for my shoestring project.

Bear that in mind when submitting bids. Assurance to return the cylinders when empty, or better yet offers to include equivalent/more empty but functional cylinders as part of payment, will be considered positively.

A component of my own vacuum system hobby project includes attempting to modify a Varian He vacuum leak detection system for use as a residual gas mass spectrometer, unless I can obtain an existing mass spectrometer residual gas analyzer. So I suppose the 3He and others may be usefull for calibration if I am unable to sell them.

I'm also struck by the degree of red tape and absurdity attached to official sales of 3He. The US government (and other governments bowing to it) have never been among my favourite entities, and in this matter it's no exception. I'll ensure the 3He is sold to a legitimate, legal buyer, in a country listed among the acceptables. But if I hear any rubbish about military/dual use restrictions, or threats of confiscation, I'll just open the valve. Maybe do the most expensive Helium Donald Duck voice impression ever. Two liters at STP should be enough for one or two quick lung fulls.


Contact: email sjm at everist.org
Location: Sydney Sth, NSW Australia

This file: http://everist.org/spacejunk/sell/helium-3.htm

Return to SpaceJunk home